Advertisement

Balance and vertical impact in sports: Role of shoe sole materials

      This paper is only available as a PDF. To read, Please Download here.

      Abstract

      Objective: Athletic shoes and mats are support surface interfaces composed of relatively soft compressible materials designed to protect against injuries occurring in sports through force of vertical impact. Impact remains high with their use because humans land harder with them. We hypothesize that this hard-landing strategy is an attempt by the user to improve stability, by compressing the material to a less destabilizing thinner-stiff variety. We tested this hypothesis by comparing impact and balance on materials consisting of ethyl-vinyl acetate (EVA) foams of varying stiffness, identical to that found in soles of athletic footwear.
      Design: Randomized-order, crossover trial, controlled comparison; blinded.
      Setting: Volunteers were selected from the general community.
      Participants: A random sample of 12 healthy men from the general population (mean age 30 years, SD ± 6). Additional selection criteria were absence of disabilities influencing ability to walk, run, and balance, and no history of frequent falls.
      Methods: Impact testing and stability measures were performed on the same test day. Ground reaction forces were measured for ten barefoot footfalls. The protocol required stepping forward from perch to surface 4.5cm below. Stability testing was performed with one-legged standing consisting of placing left foot on top of right for 30sec, barefoot, eyes open, and gaze straight, with arms to side. Subjects confronted four surface conditions presented in random order: a bare rigid platform, and the platform covered with one of three 2.5-cm-thick materials.
      Results: Steady state vertical impact was a negative function of interface stiffness, with the softest interface producing the greatest vertical impact, and the stiffest interface the least vertical impact. Vertical impact and stability measures were also negatively related, with the strongest correlation obtained with the softest interface (r = −.87, p < .001). No relation between these variables was obtained for the rigid surface.
      Conclusion: Balance and vertical impact are closely related. This supports the hypothesis that landing hard on soft surfaces is an attempt to transform the interface into a form associated with improved stability. According to these findings, currently available sports shoes and mats are too soft and thick, and should be redesigned to protect the persons using them.

      References

        • Andrish JT
        Knee injuries in gymnasts.
        Clin Sports Med. 1985; 1: 100-120
        • Brunet ME
        • Cook SD
        • Brinker MR
        • Dickson MA
        A survey of running injuries in 1505 competitive and recreational runners.
        J Sports Med Phys Fit. 1990; 30: 307-315
        • Clement DB
        • Taunton JE
        • Smart GW
        • McNicol KL
        A survey of overuse running injuries.
        Phys Sportsmed. 1981; 9: 47-58
        • James SL
        • Bates BL
        • Ostering LR
        Injuries to runners.
        Am J Sports Med. 1978; 6: 40-50
        • Dekel S
        • Weissman ML
        Joint changes after overuse and peak overloading of rabbit knees in vivo.
        Acta Orthop Scand. 1978; 49: 519-528
        • Dyck PJ
        • Classen SM
        • Stevens JC
        • O'brien PC
        Assessment of nerve damage in the feet of long distance runners.
        Mayo Clin Proc. 1987; 62: 568-572
        • Hellman DB
        • Helms CA
        • Genant HK
        Chronic repetitive trauma: a cause of atypical degenerative joint disease.
        Skeletal Radiol. 1983; 10: 236-242
        • Clarke TE
        • Fredrick EC
        • Cooper LB
        Effects of shoe cushioning upon ground reaction forces in running.
        Int J Sports Med. 1983; 4: 247-251
      1. Nigg B Biomechanics of running shoes. Human Kinetics Publishers Inc, Champaign (IL)1986
        • Mcnitt-Gray JL
        • Yokoi T
        The influence of surface characteristics on the impulse characteristics of drop landings.
        in: Proceedings of the 13th Annual Meeting of the American Society of Biomechanics. American Society of Biomechanics, Burlington (VT)1989: 92-93
        • Marti B
        Relationship between running injuries and running shoes—results of a study of 5000 participants of a 16-km run—The May 1984 Berne “Grand Prix”.
        in: Segesser B Pforringer W The shoe in sport. Year Book Medical Publishers, Chicago1989: 256-265
        • Mcnitt-Gray JL
        Landing strategy adjustments made by female gymnasts in response to drop height and mat composition.
        J Appl Biomech. 1993; 9: 173-190
        • Brocklehurst JC
        • Robertson D
        • James-Groom P
        Clinical correlates of sway in old-age sensory modalities.
        Age Ageing. 1982; 11: 1-10
        • Overstall PW
        • Exton-Smith AN
        • Imms FJ
        • Johnson AL
        Falls in the elderly related to postural imbalance.
        BMJ. 1977; 1: 261-264
        • Pyykko I
        • Jantti P
        • Aalto H
        Postural control in elderly subjects.
        Age Ageing. 1990; 19: 215-221
        • Robbins SE
        • Waked EG
        • Gouw GJ
        • McClaran J
        Athletic footwear affect balance in men.
        Br J Sports Med. 1994; 28: 117-122
        • Robbins SE
        • Gouw GJ
        • McClaran J
        Shoe sole hardness and thickness influence balance in older men.
        J Am Geriatr Soc. 1992; 40: 1089-1094
      2. Bochensky JM Methods of contemporary thought. Harper Press, New York1968
        • American Society for Testing and Materials
        Standard test method for rubber property-durometer hardness.
        in: 2nd ed. Annual book of ASTM standards. ASTM Publishers, Philadelphia1988: 596-600 (09.01)
        • Robbins SE
        • Hanna AM
        • Gouw GJ
        Overload protection: avoidance response to heavy plantar surface loading.
        Med Sci Sports Exer. 1988; 20: 85-92
        • Robbins SE
        • Hanna AM
        • Jones LA
        Sensory attenuation induced by modern athletic footwear.
        J Test Eval. 1988; 16: 412-416