Volume 87, Issue 2 , Pages 184-188, February 2006
Poststroke Fatigue: Course and Its Relation to Personal and Stroke-Related Factors
Article Outline
Abstract
Schepers VP, Visser-Meily AM, Ketelaar M, Lindeman E. Poststroke fatigue: course and its relation to personal and stroke-related factors.
Objectives
To describe the course of fatigue during the first year poststroke and to determine the relation between fatigue at 1 year poststroke and personal characteristics, stroke characteristics, and poststroke impairments.
Design
Inception cohort.
Setting
Rehabilitation center.
Participants
Patients (N=167) with a first-ever supratentorial stroke admitted for inpatient rehabilitation.
Interventions
Not applicable.
Main Outcome Measure
The Fatigue Severity Scale measured the presence and impact of fatigue at admittance for inpatient rehabilitation, as well as at 6 months and 1 year poststroke.
Results
At admission, 6 months and 1 year poststroke, fatigue was present in 51.5%, 64.1%, and 69.5% of the patients, respectively. Fatigue impact 1 year poststroke was greater among patients with more depressive symptoms, higher age, women, and patients with a locus of control more directed to powerful others.
Conclusions
Because fatigue impact is an increasing problem during the first year poststroke, it deserves more attention in clinical practice and scientific research. Locus of control and depression are related to poststroke fatigue and might be important foci for future interventions.
Key Words: Cerebrovascular accident , Fatigue , Longitudinal studies , Outcome assessment (health care) , Rehabilitation
FATIGUE IS A COMMON COMPLAINT in stroke patients1, 2 and can contribute to functional limitations,1, 3 institutionalization, and mortality.3 Only a few articles have described the results of studies on self-reported fatigue in a population of stroke patients.
The percentage of stroke patients reporting fatigue problems ranges from 39% to 68%.1, 2, 3, 4 These estimates are based on studies with cross-sectional designs. There are few data available on the course of poststroke fatigue. In cross-sectional studies,1, 2, 4 no association has been found between the poststroke time interval and fatigue. Longitudinal data have not yet been published.
Little evidence is available on factors associated with poststroke fatigue. Depression is the only poststroke impairment with an undeniable relation to poststroke fatigue.5 Nevertheless, it is important to realize that poststroke fatigue can also develop independently of depression.1, 2, 3, 4 Other factors must therefore play a role in the development of poststroke fatigue. Contradictory results have been found for the relation of personal factors, such as age and sex, to poststroke fatigue.1, 3, 4 Glader et al3 found that patients who lived alone were more fatigued than patients who lived with a partner. Moreover, they found that fatigue was more common in patients who were activity-of-daily-living-dependent before their stroke,3 indicating that prestroke health condition and comorbidity could be of importance. Several authors6, 7 have suggested that fatigue could be the result of inadequate coping with the consequences of a stroke, and recommended to examine prestroke psychologic factors in future studies. With respect to stroke-related variables, no relation has been found between poststroke fatigue and type of stroke or hemisphere.1, 3, 4 With respect to poststroke impairments, cognitive disorders seem to play an important role in poststroke fatigue on clinical grounds. Self-experienced neuropsychologic problems showed some association to poststroke fatigue in a study of van der Werf et al.2 Sleeping problems have frequently been reported poststroke8 and a relation with poststroke fatigue seems likely.
We conclude that evidence on determinants of poststroke fatigue is still limited. Results were not always unequivocal, and difficult to compare because of differences in the determinants studied and the poststroke time interval between and within studies.1, 2, 4 Like other authors,9, 10 we conclude that more attention should be given to exploring the factors contributing to poststroke fatigue, as this could lead to the development of treatment options. Our study aimed (1) to describe the course of fatigue during the first year poststroke and (2) to determine the relation between fatigue 1 year poststroke and personal characteristics, stroke characteristics, and poststroke impairments.
Methods
Participants
Subjects were selected from stroke patients consecutively admitted to 4 Dutch rehabilitation centers (see Acknowledgments) according to the following inclusion criteria: (1) admittance for inpatient rehabilitation, (2) first-ever stroke, (3) unilateral supratentorial lesion, and (4) age above 18. Exclusion criteria were (1) disabling comorbidity (prestroke Barthel Index score <18), (2) inability to speak Dutch, and (3) aphasia. The medical ethics committees of University Medical Center Utrecht and the participating rehabilitation centers approved the study.
Procedure
At the start of inpatient rehabilitation, patients were invited by their rehabilitation physician to participate in the study. Informed consent was obtained from all patients. Personal and stroke characteristics were recorded at the first assessment, which took place as soon as possible after admission. Poststroke impairments were assessed at 1 year poststroke. Fatigue was measured at the first assessment, and then 6 months and 1 year poststroke. All assessments were carried out by trained research assistants.
Measures
FatigueWe used the Fatigue Severity Scale (FSS)4, 11 (appendix1) to evaluate poststroke fatigue. It assesses the impact of fatigue on daily life. The FSS is a brief and simple instrument and is therefore feasible for stroke patients. It consists of 9 statements about fatigue scored on a 7-point scale, ranging from 1 (strongly disagree) to 7 (strongly agree). The total score is the mean of the 9 item scores. The higher the FSS score, the more impact that fatigue has on daily life. The FSS was originally designed to evaluate the impact of fatigue in patients with multiple sclerosis,11 but it has also been used in patients with stroke.4 In the current study, the internal consistency of the FSS, measured using the Cronbach α, was .89. Fatigue was scored as present if the FSS score was above 4.12 A score above 4 indicates a moderate to high impact of fatigue on daily living.
Personal characteristicsData on age, sex, marital status, and comorbidity were obtained from medical records. Locus of control is a psychologic characteristic defined as “the degree to which individuals perceive events in their lives as being the consequence of their own actions, and thereby controllable (internal control), or as being unrelated to their own behavior, and therefore beyond personal control (external control).” The Multidimensional Health Locus of Control Scale (MHLC)13 focuses on perceptions concerning the locus of control over health-related outcomes. The MHLC has 3 subscales, each consisting of 6 items scored on a 6-point scale. The internal subscale assesses the extent to which a person believes health is a function of his/her own behavior. The 2 other subscales assess the externally orientated beliefs. The chance subscale assesses the degree to which a person believes his health is unpredictable, a matter of fate, luck, or chance. The powerful others subscale assesses the extent to which a person believes that health is largely determined by the actions of physicians.
Stroke characteristicsData on type of stroke and hemisphere were obtained from medical records. Type of stroke was classified as ischemic versus hemorrhagic (intracerebral hemorrhage, subarachnoid hemorrhage).
Poststroke impairmentsThe Motricity Index14, 15 is a brief assessment method for motor impairment that scores the level of hemiparesis from 0 (paralysis) to 100 (normal strength). Cognitive functions were evaluated using 2 methods.
First, the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE)16 is a widely used brief screening instrument. It tests orientation, memory, attention, calculation, language, and construction functions. A subject who scored less than 24 on the MMSE was considered to have cognitive impairments.
Second, the Trail-Making Test part B (TMT-B)17 indicates the level of executive functioning. It involves complex visual scanning, motor speed, and attention. The participant has to connect 25 encircled numbers and letters, as quickly as possible, alternating between numbers and letters (1-a-2-b-3-c, etc). Both the time taken to complete the tests and the number of correct connections are recorded. We used the Center of Epidemiologic Studies Depression (CES-D) scale18 to assess depression. It is a self-reporting questionnaire with 20 items and investigates mood over the past 7 days. A subject scoring above 16 was considered to be depressed.19 One item of the Rehabilitation Activities Profile20 was used to evaluate the presence of sleeping problems.
Statistical Analysis
We used descriptive statistics (means and standard deviations [SDs]; medians, and interquartile ranges) to describe the baseline characteristics. A 1-way repeated-measures analysis of variance was performed to compare FSS scores at admission and at 6 months and 1 year poststroke. We used univariate analysis to examine the relations between the FSS scores and the independent variables (ie, personal characteristics, stroke characteristics, poststroke impairments). Variables with a significance level below 0.5 in the univariate analysis were selected for the multivariate regression analysis. Backward linear regression analysis was used until the remaining variables had a significance level below 0.1. This selection, with a more liberal significance level, increased the power for selection of true associated determinants and limited the bias in the regression coefficients.21
Results
A total of 228 patients were included in the study. Eight patients died before the 1-year follow-up, 15 had a recurrent stroke, 21 refused further participation, and 17 patients had missing scores on 1 or more measures. Thus, data from 167 patients were available for analysis.
Patients were relatively young, and the majority lived with a partner (table 1). Infarctions were more frequent than hemorrhages. At 1 year poststroke, 11.4% of the patients were considered cognitively impaired as indicated by the score on the MMSE. The CES-D score indicated a depression in 25.7% of patients.
Table 1. Descriptives of Personal Characteristics, Stroke Characteristics, and Poststroke Impairments
| Characteristic | Subjects (N=167) |
|---|---|
| Personal characteristics | |
| 56.4±11.4 | |
| 41.3 | |
| 55.1 | |
| 73.7 | |
| 21.8±5.0 | |
| 20.8±5.4 | |
| 20.3±5.4 | |
| Stroke characteristics | |
| 6.0 | |
| 58.7 | |
| 68.9 | |
| Impairments at 1 year poststroke | |
| 70.7±25.4 | |
| 28.0 | |
| 123.0 | |
| 24.0 | |
| 10.7±8.2 | |
| 33.5 |
Course of Poststroke Fatigue
Fatigue was present at admission, and at 6 months and 1 year poststroke in 51.5%, 64.1%, and 69.5% of the patients, respectively (table 2). In 37.7% of the patients, fatigue was present at all 3 assessments (fig 1); fatigue was only absent at all 3 assessments in 17.4% of the patients. A more variable course of fatigue during the first year poststroke was shown in the remaining 44.9% of the patients. Of the patients who reported fatigue at 1 year poststroke, 29.3% were also depressed. Table 2 presents means and SDs of FSS scores at the different poststroke time intervals. There was a significant effect of time (F2,165=10.95, P<.000).
Table 2. Descriptive Statistics for FSS Scores for Admission to Rehabilitation Center, 6 Months, and 1 Year Poststroke (N=167)
| Measurement Period | % Fatigued | Mean FSS Score ± SD |
|---|---|---|
| Admission | 51.5 | 4.1±1.3 |
| 6 months poststroke | 64.1 | 4.5±1.2 |
| 1 year poststroke | 69.5 | 4.7±1.3 |

Fig 1.
Number (and proportion) of patients who reported fatigue at admission, 6 months, and 1 year poststroke (N=167).
Regression Analyses
Table 3 presents univariate correlation coefficients between FSS scores 1 year poststroke and the independent variables (ie, personal characteristics, stroke characteristics, poststroke impairments). The highest correlation coefficients were found for the CES-D, followed by the MHLC powerful others subscale and age. The variables included in the multivariate backward analysis were age, sex, all subscales of the MHLC, marital status, type of stroke, CES-D, and sleeping problems. The multivariate model (see table 3) included age, sex, MHLC powerful others subscale, and the CES-D, and explained 21% of the total variance (adjusted R2=.20) of FSS scores 1 year poststroke.
Table 3. Univariate and Multivariate Analyses Between Personal Characteristics, Stroke Characteristics, and Poststroke Impairments and the FSS Score 1 Year Poststroke (N=167)
| Determinants | Univariate Analysis | Multivariate Analysis | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pearson r | P | β | P | |
| Personal characteristics | ||||
| .18 | .02⁎† | .17 | .02⁎ | |
| .15 | .06⁎† | .14 | .06⁎ | |
| −.07 | .35† | NS | ||
| .12 | .12† | NS | ||
| .24 | .002⁎† | .12 | .09⁎ | |
| .04 | .64 | NA | ||
| −.11 | .18† | NS | ||
| Stroke characteristics | ||||
| .03 | .73 | NA | ||
| .06 | .41† | NS | ||
| Poststroke impairments | ||||
| −.05 | .53 | NA | ||
| .03 | .68 | NA | ||
| .03 | .67 | NA | ||
| −.03 | .67 | NA | ||
| .39 | <.001⁎† | .34 | <.001⁎ | |
| .12 | .11† | NS | ||
⁎ P<0.1. |
† Determinants included in multivariate regression analysis. |
Discussion
The percentage of patients reporting fatigue increased over time: its prevalence increased from half of the patients at admission to two thirds of the patients at 1 year poststroke. Fatigue impact scores increased significantly during the first year poststroke. Fatigue impact at 1 year poststroke was greater among patients with more depressive symptoms, higher age, female sex, and patients with a locus of control more directed to powerful others.
The prevalence of poststroke fatigue was comparable to the estimates reported in the literature, which range from 39% to 68%.1, 2, 3, 4 The relatively low percentage of 39% was found in a study that excluded patients who reported that they always felt depressed.3 The impact of fatigue increased during the first year poststroke. This might be because in the first phase after their stroke, patients have to deal with many consequences. They could experience fatigue as a “minor” problem compared with their other impairments and functional limitations. At 1 year poststroke when most of the recovery has taken place, fatigue could remain as an important problem with disabling consequences for everyday life. The impact of fatigue could become more relevant as patients try to resume their work and social activities, and the demands of daily life increase.
In patient education, which is a first and important step in the management of fatigue problems, health care professionals must inform patients about the likelihood of experiencing fatigue after suffering a stroke, even long after the event. This will enable patients and their families to anticipate future problems and allow them to gain recognition for this problem. This may diminish distress and misunderstanding when fatigue problems occur.22
Depression was an important determinant of fatigue impact in our study and this agrees with earlier findings.1, 2, 3 Nevertheless, depression and fatigue must be seen as distinct poststroke consequences1, 2, 3, 4, 5 because three quarters of the patients with moderate to high fatigue impact were not depressed. Other factors were also related to poststroke fatigue. The demographic variables age and sex were significantly related to poststroke fatigue as was found by Glader et al.3 Moreover, our study investigated the health locus of control beliefs. The powerful others subscale, one of the externally orientated subscales, was found to be related to poststroke fatigue. A higher belief of control directed to physicians was associated with higher levels of fatigue impact. Some others found associations between locus of control and health outcome. A high internal locus of control was associated with faster recovery from physical disability in stroke patients.23 A low internal locus of control or high external locus of control was associated with more fatigue problems in patients with chronic fatigue syndrome24 and with a chronic anxiety disorder.25 A more favorable outcome was also shown to be related to high internal and low external control in other patient groups, that is, patients with traumatic brain injury,26 spinal cord injury,27 and chronic low back pain.28
In clinical practice, stroke patients who have made a good physical recovery often have disabling fatigue problems. Patients with a lacunar infarction, who all had a maximum score on the Barthel Index, reported many emotional disturbances and fatigue problems.29 Patients with good physical recovery seemed to be the most disabled by fatigue.6 We did not find support for this idea because motor impairment was not associated with fatigue impact. In our study population, patients with both good and poor motor recovery experienced fatigue problems.
Cognitive impairments were studied because, on clinical grounds, it could be expected that these would be related to fatigue impact. Limited attention capacity was found in patients with lacunar infarction who also reported fatigue.29 As a result of cognitive problems, many tasks cost more mental effort and it seems plausible that this would give rise to fatigue. However, we did not find a relation between fatigue impact and cognitive disorders. This might have been attributable to our assessment methods for cognitive impairments: the MMSE, which is only a global screening instrument, and 1 test for executive functioning (the TMT), were the instruments we used. To clarify the relation between cognitive impairments and poststroke fatigue, additional research with more extensive neuropsychologic assessments is needed.
The determinants depression, age, sex, and locus of control explained one fifth of the variance of fatigue impact scores. Therefore, most fatigue impact remained unexplained. We expect that a number of factors we did not take into account might be associated with poststroke fatigue. For example, the level of physical fitness30, 31 could be an important factor contributing to poststroke fatigue. Fatigue could be the side effect of using certain medications.10 Sleep apnea, which is commonly associated with stroke,8 might also be important.32 Environmental factors and personal characteristics, such as coping strategies, might be relevant for poststroke fatigue as well. Additional research is needed to clarify the impact of such factors on poststroke fatigue.
We studied the factors potentially associated with poststroke fatigue because exploring the underlying mechanism of poststroke fatigue could support the development of intervention strategies. Depression is probably an important focus for interventions for poststroke fatigue. It is known that depressive symptoms can improve with medication. The preference is currently given to the selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors.5 The question is whether administration of an antidepressant that alleviates the symptoms of depression could also reduce fatigue problems. There are indications that selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors sometimes reduce fatigue levels in patients with multiple sclerosis and cancer.10 Additional research is needed to examine the effects of antidepressants on poststroke fatigue in both depressed and nondepressed patients.
In addition to depression, locus of control could be an interesting focus for future interventions. Some consider locus of control to be a fairly stable psychologic characteristic. However, it is far more likely that health locus of control beliefs can change over time. Changes in locus of control beliefs were found after dramatic illness-related experiences.33 A multidisciplinary treatment program was shown to be effective in changing locus of control beliefs in patients with chronic pain.34 It would be interesting to investigate whether locus of control beliefs can be changed in stroke patients and whether these changes would have a positive effect on health outcome. Indications for this can be found in studies of other patient populations. In cancer patients, tailored counseling was shown to be effective with respect to locus of control and fatigue.35 A mind-body wellness intervention for older adults with chronic illness led to a significant decrease in external locus of control and a decrease in sleeping problems, pain, anxiety and depression.36
Conclusions
Fatigue is an important poststroke impairment and its impact on everyday life increased during the first year poststroke. Depression, age, sex, and health-related locus of control were related to poststroke fatigue. Patient education on poststroke fatigue should be routinely given to patients and their families. Depression and locus of control could become important foci for interventions. Future research should focus on a more detailed exploration of the determinants of poststroke fatigue and on evaluating interventions for this.
Acknowledgments
The FuPro study group is Guus J. Lankhorst, Joost Dekker, Annet J. Dallmeijer, Maarten J. IJzerman, Heleen Beckerman, and Vincent de Groot from VU University Medical Center Amsterdam (project coordination); Arie J. Prevo, Eline Lindeman, Vera P. Schepers, and Ingrid G. van de Port from University Medical Center, Utrecht; Henk J. Stam, Else Odding, and Bianca van Baalen from Erasmus Medical Center, Rotterdam; and Anita Beelen and Imelda J. de Groot from Amsterdam Medical Center, Amsterdam. We thank the participating rehabilitation centers: De Hoogstraat, Utrecht; Rehabilitation Center Amsterdam, Amsterdam; Heliomare, Wijk aan Zee; and Blixembosch, Eindhoven.
APPENDIX 1.
Coding categorization by spinal cord level and completeness of injury⁎
| Statement |
|---|
| 1. My motivation is lower when I am fatigued. |
| 2. Exercise brings on my fatigue. |
| 3. I am easily fatigued. |
| 4. Fatigue interferes with my physical functioning. |
| 5. Fatigue causes frequent problems for me. |
| 6. My fatigue prevents sustained physical functioning. |
| 7. Fatigue interferes with carrying out certain duties and responsibilities. |
| 8. Fatigue is among my three most disabling symptoms. |
| 9. Fatigue interferes with my work, family, or social life. |
⁎ Patients are instructed to choose a number from 1 to 7 that indicates the degree of agreement with each statement where 1 indicates strongly disagree and 7 strongly agree. |
References
- . Fatigue after stroke . Arch Phys Med Rehabil . 1999;80:173–178
- . Experience of severe fatigue long after stroke and its relation to depressive symptoms and disease characteristics . Eur Neurol . 2001;45:28–33
- . Poststroke fatigue. A 2-year follow-up study of stroke patients in Sweden . Stroke . 2002;33:1327–1333
- . Poststroke fatigue (characteristics and related factors) . Cerebrovasc Dis . 2005;19:84–90
- . Depression and fatigue after stroke . In: Barnes MP , Dobkin BH , Bogousslavsky J editor. Recovery after stroke . New York: Cambridge Univ Pr; 2005;p. 556–579
- . Fatigue after stroke (a major but neglected issue) . Cerebrovasc Dis . 2001;12:75–81
- . Diffuse cerebral symptoms in convalescents from cerebral infarction and myocardial infarction . Acta Neurol Scand . 1983;67:348–355
- Time course of sleep-related breathing disorders in first-ever stroke or transient ischemic attack . Am J Respir Crit Care Med . 2000;161:375–380
- . Post-stroke depression or fatigue . Eur Neurol . 2001;45:3–5
- . Fatigue associated with stroke and other neurologic conditions (implications for stroke rehabilitation) . Arch Phys Med Rehabil . 2003;84:1714–1720
- . The fatigue severity scale (application to patients with multiple sclerosis and systemic lupus erythematosus) . Arch Neurol . 1989;46:1121–1123
- . Efficacy of an energy conservation course for persons with multiple sclerosis . Arch Phys Med Rehabil . 2001;82:449–456
- . Development of the Multidimensional Health Locus of Control Scales . Health Educ Monogr . 1978;6:160–166
- . Motor evaluation in vascular hemiplegia . Eur Neurol . 1980;19:382–389
- . Assessing motor impairment after stroke (a pilot reliability study) . J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry . 1990;53:576–579
- . “Mini-mental state.” A practical method for grading the cognitive state of patients for the clinician . J Psychiatr Res . 1975;12:189–198
- . The validity of the Trail Making Test as an indicator of organic brain damage . Percept Motor Skills . 1958;8:271–276
- . The CES-D Scale (a self-report depression scale for research in the general population) . Appl Psychol Meas . 1977;1:385–401
- . Criterion validity of the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression scale (CES-D) (results from a community-based sample of older subjects in The Netherlands) . Psychol Med . 1997;27:231–235
- . The rehabilitation activities profile (a validation study of its use as a disability index with stroke patients) . Arch Phys Med Rehabil . 1995;76:501–507
- . Prognostic modelling with logistic regression analysis (a comparison of selection and estimation methods in small data sets) . Stat Med . 2000;19:1059–1079
- . Fatigue and stroke . Rehabil Nurs . 2002;27:89–94 103
- . Perceived control of recovery from physical disability (measurement and prediction) . Br J Clin Psychol . 1989;28(Pt 1):53–59
- . Coping and other predictors of outcome in chronic fatigue syndrome (a 1-year follow-up) . J Psychosom Res . 1997;43:405–415
- . Locus of control in chronic anxiety disorders . Acta Psychiatr Scand . 1985;72:529–535
- . Coping strategies and locus of control following traumatic brain injury (relationship to long-term outcome) . Brain Inj . 1992;6:89–94
- . The pattern of coping in persons with spinal cord injuries . Disabil Rehabil . 2000;22:501–507
- . Health locus of control beliefs and psychological distress as predictors for treatment outcome in low-back pain patients (results of a 3-month follow-up of a controlled intervention study) . Pain . 1991;46:35–41
- . Decreased capacity for mental effort after single supratentorial lacunar infarct may affect performance in everyday life . J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry . 1998;65:697–702
- . Physiological outcomes of aerobic exercise training in hemiparetic stroke patients . Stroke . 1995;26:101–105
- . Exercise capacity early after stroke . Arch Phys Med Rehabil . 2002;83:1697–1702
- . Sleep apnea, delirium, depressed mood, cognition, and ADL ability after stroke . J Am Geriatr Soc . 2001;49:391–397
- . Reliability and validity of the health locus of control scale . J Pers Assess . 1982;46:614–619
- . Multidisciplinary treatment of chronic pain patients (its efficacy in changing patient locus of control) . Arch Phys Med Rehabil . 2000;81:739–740
- . Effects of psychological treatment on cancer patients (a critical review) . Psychosom Med . 1992;54:489–517
- . A classroom mind/body wellness intervention for older adults with chronic illness (comparing immediate and 1-year benefits) . Behav Med . 2001;27:15–27
Supported by The Netherlands Organization for Health Research and Development (grant no. 1435.0001), as part of the Functional prognostication and disability study on neurological disorders (FuPro), supervised by the Department of Rehabilitation Medicine of the VU Medical Center, Amsterdam.
No commercial party having a direct financial interest in the results of the research supporting this article has or will confer a benefit upon the authors or upon any organization with which the authors are associated.
PII: S0003-9993(05)01291-8
doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2005.10.005
© 2006 American Congress of Rehabilitation Medicine and the American Academy of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Volume 87, Issue 2 , Pages 184-188, February 2006
